Martin gilbert churchill biography lion
•
Q: How to they differ?
I’ve been slogging through the William Manchester Churchill trilogy, The Last Lion. How is Hillsdale’s eight volume Winston S. Churchillby Randolph Churchill and Martin Gilbert different? —M.A., Louisiana.
A: Profoundly, but both are invaluable
(This article is excerpted from a longer piece which can read in entirety on the Hillsdale College Churchill Project.) If you are slogging through Manchester, you may find Gilbert a challenge. There is a vast difference, both writers have their advantages, but Gilbert is the source on which scholars rely.
Music by Churchill, Lyrics by Manchester
William Manchester was a stylist, a lyrical, beautiful writer. But comparing him to Gilbert, Simon Schama was critical: “Manchester’s slapdash study, with its cartoon-strip account of British politics and culture and its rhinestone-studded prose, looked particularly gaudy next to Gil
•
May 16, 2016
Sir Martin Gilbert’s Indexes Have Been Digitized
By LADY (ESTHER) GILBERT
There are tens of thousands of pages in the Official Churchill Biography—but what if you are looking for specific information on Gallipoli? Enigma and the German plans to invade Britain? Churchill’s relationship with Clementine, with Halifax, with Pétain, with Stalin, with “Admiral Q”? How to know where to look, which volume of narrative, which edition of documents, to find the characters and events that spanned Churchill’s life, those he touched, those who worked with him, those he influenced? If you have the book, you could look it up in the Index. But which volume—which volumes—cover it? And taken altogether the Indexes for the complete biography runs to 711 pages—a weighty tome in itself!
Churchill’s vast world as defined, explored, developed and elucidated in Martin Gilbert’s multi-volume Churchill biography are now available and searchable online—through the itemized an
•
Two Biographers: you can’t read one without the other
A reader asks for “a klar summary of Martin Gilbert’s and William Manchester’s writing styles, reminding me of the vast but complementary difference between Churchill’s two most famous biographers.
There are big differences between them, but both should be read for a full appreciation of Churchill. In 1986, as Manchester was completing Volume II of The gods Lion, he received an encouraging note from Gilbert: “Our work proceeds on parallel tracks.”
William Manchester
Manchester was a literary stylist of the first magnitude, which fryst vatten quickly apparent from the sonorous, emotive, rolling phrases of The Last Lion, reflecting the skill that earlier brought us Death of a Presidentand American Caesar, his masterpiece on Douglas MacArthur. But Manchester’s sources are more restricted.
Manchester could be careless with facts. He sometimes of